
or
the past several weeks, we've been making lists and checking them
twice — in some cases, four and five times — searching
for what we think are the top 20 books of the year. And, as always,
we were in for a few surprises and disappointments. Something
that didn’t surprise us, and was a trend we mentioned
two
years ago, was the growing popularity of narrative food books.
This year, it seems, was the tipping point. Unflinching looks
behind the food world and at our food supply, autobiographies,
post-James Frey memoirs that stick to the truth (or so we hope)
have all risen to the top of our list. In an article written earlier
this year by Bill Daley of the
Chicago Tribune titled "Food
Memoirs Replace Recipes," he states, "Reading about
food has become almost as red-hot a subject in America as eating." He
continues by quoting Rux Martin, executive editor of cookbooks
at Houghton Mifflin Co., as she speaks about the market for these
books: " 'It's a way broader audience. It's easier to read
about someone's experience with food [in these books] than to
cook from them. Everyone thinks about food; not everyone is so
dedicated they want to spend money on a cookbook.' "
If our readers are any indication, people are still very interested
in buying cookbooks — some from expected categories, such
as baking, chocolate, and hyper-popular ethnic cuisines like
Italian. But we also found interest, no doubt due to excellent
books written by talented authors, in lesser-known cuisines,
such as African, Turkish, and Lebanese.
That being said, the work for which we reserve top honors this
year isn’t a cookbook, but rather Michael Pollan's The
Omnivore's Dilemma. If you haven't read it, do
yourself the favor. It's one of the most important food books
to come along in memory. In it Pollan traces four meals back
to their natural roots: a McDonald's lunch eaten on the go,
a meal made with ingredients from Whole Foods, a chicken dinner
cooked with foods from a small über-organic Virginia farm,
and a banquet comprised of items Pollan foraged and hunted.
You'll be fascinated, horrified, awestruck, and think twice
about the foods you put in your body. Plus we guarantee you'll
never look at corn the same way again.
In addition to our 20 best, honorable mentions go to A
Culinary Traveller in Tuscany by Beth Elon (Little Bookroom), My
Life in France by Julia Child with Alex Prud'Homme (Knopf), Keys
to the Cellar by Peter Demeter (Wiley), The
Cake Book by Tish Boyle (Wiley), and The
Red Cat Cookbook by Jimmy Bradley (Clarkson Potter).
Congratulations to all the winners.